Next Insurance vs HiscoxHonest 2026 Comparison for Small Business Owners
Next Insurance and Hiscox are two of the most-searched small business insurance carriers — both offer fast online quotes, digital-first experiences, and broad industry eligibility. But they're built for different types of businesses, price very differently, and have meaningfully different strengths and weaknesses. Here's an honest breakdown of both — plus the question neither of them wants you to ask.
Quick Answer
- ✅ Next Insurance is better for: Contractors, trades, businesses needing workers comp, mobile operations
- ✅ Hiscox is better for: Professional services, E&O/cyber, white-collar businesses, international operations
- ⚡ The real answer: Neither may be your best rate. Both price broadly — specialty and regional carriers routinely beat both for specific industries.
Head-to-Head: Next Insurance vs Hiscox (2026)
| Category | Next Insurance | Hiscox |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 2016 | 1901 |
| AM Best Rating | A- (Excellent) | A (Excellent) |
| Available States | All 50 states | All 50 states |
| Online Quote Time | ~7 minutes | ~10 minutes |
| Certificate of Insurance | Instant digital | Instant digital |
| General Liability | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| BOP (GL + Property) | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Professional Liability / E&O | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes — specialty strength |
| Workers Compensation | ✅ Yes (most states) | ❌ Not offered |
| Commercial Auto | ✅ Yes | ❌ Limited |
| Cyber Liability | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes — specialty strength |
| Inland Marine | ✅ Yes | ❌ Limited |
| Umbrella | ❌ Limited | ✅ Yes |
| Best For Industry | Contractors, trades, service businesses | Professional services, consulting, creative |
| GL Starting Price | ~$25/mo | ~$22/mo |
| BOP Starting Price | ~$45/mo | ~$55/mo |
| J.D. Power Rating | Not yet rated | Above average |
| Claims Filing | App / online / phone | Online / phone / broker |
| Local Agent Option | ❌ No | ❌ No |
| Coverage Cancellation | Monthly, no penalty | Annual, prorated refund |
Price Comparison by Business Type
| Business Type | Next GL/mo | Hiscox GL/mo | Market Range | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| General Contractor | $85–$150 | $100–$180 | $70–$250 | Next (usually) |
| Plumber / HVAC | $70–$120 | $80–$140 | $65–$200 | Next (usually) |
| IT Consultant | $35–$65 | $30–$60 | $28–$90 | Hiscox (usually) |
| Marketing Consultant | $25–$50 | $22–$45 | $20–$70 | Hiscox (usually) |
| Landscaping | $65–$120 | $70–$130 | $55–$180 | Next (usually) |
| Cleaning Service | $45–$85 | $50–$90 | $40–$120 | Next (usually) |
| Personal Trainer | $25–$45 | $22–$40 | $18–$65 | Mixed |
| Photographer | $25–$40 | $20–$38 | $18–$60 | Hiscox (usually) |
| Accountant / CPA | $45–$80 (GL only) | $40–$75 (GL only) | $35–$100 | Hiscox (usually) |
Estimates based on national averages for solo/small businesses. Actual quotes vary by state, revenue, and claims history. "Market Range" shows the full market including specialty carriers.
Next Insurance — Where It Wins
Next Insurance was built for contractors and trades — they have broader eligibility for construction-related businesses, include workers comp in most states, and offer commercial auto. Their app is fast and the certificate of insurance is genuinely instant. For a plumber, electrician, or general contractor who needs GL + workers comp in one place, Next Insurance is hard to beat on convenience and price.
Where Next falls short: Shorter claims history, not yet J.D. Power rated, and their underwriting for complex or high-risk businesses is less sophisticated than older carriers. Their pricing can be inconsistent — sometimes notably higher than the market for certain industries.
Hiscox — Where It Wins
Hiscox has 120+ years of underwriting experience and specializes in professional services — E&O for consultants, cyber for tech companies, media liability for agencies. Their professional liability products are more sophisticated than Next's, and they have a longer claims track record. Above-average J.D. Power scores reflect a more mature claims operation.
Where Hiscox falls short: No workers comp in most markets, limited commercial auto, and higher starting prices for many trade businesses. International operations are a strength but most small US businesses don't need that capability.
The Question Neither Carrier Wants You to Ask
Next Insurance and Hiscox are two of thousands of carriers in the US commercial insurance market. Both price based on broad industry categories — the same rate for a plumber in Iowa as a plumber in Manhattan. Specialty and regional carriers price your specific risk profile, location, and revenue. The full-market comparison wins on price 60–70% of the time.
Compare 50+ Carriers in Minutes →By clicking, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy. Consent is not required to get a quote.
Claims Experience Compared
| Factor | Next Insurance | Hiscox |
|---|---|---|
| Years underwriting | 8 years | 120+ years |
| J.D. Power rating | Not rated | Above average |
| Average claim response time | 24–48 hrs (reported) | 48–72 hrs (reported) |
| Online claims filing | ✅ App + web | ✅ Web |
| Dedicated claims rep | Not always | ✅ Usually |
| Trustpilot (US) score | 4.1/5 (limited reviews) | 4.2/5 |
| BBB Rating | A+ | A+ |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Next Insurance or Hiscox better for small business?▼
Next Insurance is generally better for contractors, trades, and businesses that need workers comp bundled with GL. Hiscox is generally better for professional services (E&O, cyber), white-collar businesses, and international operations. For most small businesses, neither is definitively better — the right answer depends on your industry, state, and specific coverage needs. Comparing quotes across multiple carriers (not just these two) typically finds a better rate.
Is Next Insurance cheaper than Hiscox?▼
Next Insurance tends to price 15–30% lower than Hiscox for contractors and trades. Hiscox is more competitive for professional services and E&O. Neither is universally cheaper. Both offer instant online quotes — compare them side by side for your specific business type and state before deciding.
Does Next Insurance offer workers compensation?▼
Yes. Next Insurance offers workers comp in most states. Hiscox does not offer workers comp in most markets. If you need workers comp bundled with your GL or BOP, Next Insurance is the better option between these two.
Which has better claims service — Next Insurance or Hiscox?▼
Hiscox has a longer claims track record (100+ years of underwriting) and consistently scores above average in J.D. Power satisfaction surveys. Next Insurance has improved significantly since 2021 but has a shorter history. For businesses where claims response speed matters most, Hiscox's experience is a meaningful advantage.
Are there better alternatives to both Next Insurance and Hiscox?▼
Yes, frequently. Both Next Insurance and Hiscox are online-first carriers that price based on broad risk categories. Specialty and regional carriers often price specific business types significantly lower. Platforms that compare across 50+ carriers simultaneously tend to find better rates than going directly to either carrier. The biggest mistake small businesses make is stopping at the first or most-advertised quote.
Don't Stop at Two Quotes
Compare rates from 50+ carriers for your specific business type. Takes about 5 minutes. No agent calls required.
Get My Full Market Quote →By clicking, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy.